Shankar's Boys Movie Review :

Shankar’s Boys Movie Review : Maathi Yosi, That’s what we say (Think Different)

(Read from the 2nd paragraph if you aren’t familiar with Tamil)

Inga panam illaama irukara ovvoru payanukkum padippu kedaikanum,
Padippu ezhaingalukku etta kaniyakida kudathunu thaan sir naan ippadi paninen – Gentleman

Zoom…

Naattaiye azhikera oru governor irundha enna illana enna – Kadhalan

Zoom…

Podhupanithurai, Pokuvarathuthurai, Kalvi, Sugadhaaram, Minsaram ippadi
ella thurailayum lanjam vaangi vaangi naatai seer kedhututeenga – Indian

Zoom…

Indha America cosmetics ellam nekku pidikaathu. enakku therinchathellam thallaikku seiyakkai, udambukku manjal thool. Please itha ellam edhutundu poidungoo – Jeans

Zoom…

Enakku thevayellam ettu mani nera thookam, poo pola naalu idli, pudhina chatney, mansakku niraivana vellai, appa ammavoda oru kai rummy, pooncholai kiramathilai oru azhaghana ratchashi – Mudhalvan

Zoom…

And now BOYS.

Completing half-a-dozen movies successfully with BOYS is the whiz kid Shankar. Brought up in the neighborhoods of Chennai and having done his schooling and college in Chennai, this is shankar’s wish to celebrate the coming of the age of adolescence. His boldness to describe BOYS as they are has helped him to come out of his pedestrian fantasy movies.

Keeping out the controversies of the media to the end of this review, Boys is a movie with no false pretensions, no intended puns and a no-nonsense movie. Even if you have the smallest nail in the world, I can write the story on it. Five guys and a girl find their hidden talents due to unforeseen situations and take an elevator to their career. The thread that unites them is friendship and love. What begins as a small time eve teasing ends up in a relationship that displays a spectrum of emotions, debacles and re-unions.

Sidharth playing the quasi-hero, leaves a distinctive influence of a typical lover boy in us. Harini playing the full-time heroine is the most natural of all the characters. To use an often used cliche, amazingly brilliant performance. Not a typical heroine to just run around those lavender farms. To our surprise, she often gives a FINGER. Good one.

The other BOYS have done their best and ‘natural acting’ comes so easily to them. That innocent looking Kumar has given a flambuyoant performance. Vivek as Mangalam sir is a typical drunkard whom we find in every other bar in Chennai. He has downplayed his comic sense to match the character. The surprise is senthil’s cameo role. It is a sure shot shankar punch to explain Information is wealth through a most unassuming character of senthil. Glimpses of classic characterization.

A loosely written screenplay has let down shankar’s ambition of unfolding the carpet of The Pimple Age. Nearly the first half of the movie is spent to wade through the life of collegers. But there is honesty in the depiction. Every mischief of these boys is nothing but true. None of them has the slightest exaggeration. From girls to cigarettes to beers to porno movies to ‘first experiences’ do happen in the life of a college guy. Trying to pack all these mischief’s among these five boys made the boys look like bad exceptions of the college crowd. Though everyone who has gone through that phase could feel a pinch of them in these boys. If you can’t, write-off, you are an exception.

A R Rahman has added his part to the celebration. Seven songs which are certainly the best of tamil music, this year. Vaali’s lyrics for the Secret of Success is the best of all. The small songs, which haven’t appeared in the CDs, are worth a mention. ARR – Shankar combination is known for fantastic BGMs like Ni Sa Ri Sa in jeans etc.. ARR has not done his best in BGMs for Boys like what he did for the songs. Not a single BGM stays back in our minds.

Writer Sujatha‘s down-to-earth dialogues forms the core of the movie. Bringing in the local taminglish lingo of chennai has been a cakewalk for him. The punch comes when harini replies to her father, who ditched his lover for wealth. She says ” You kept my name as harini because it was your ex-girlfriends name. You are still living in thoughts of her. I don’t want to repeat you. I cannot ditch my boyfriend (munna) and then keep my son’s name as munna“. Listen to these lines with the context and you would appreciate it. Except for some dialogues, which are explicit, sujatha proves he is a clean observer of surroundings. The wineshop scene where the boys meet mangalam sir is typical. Dialogues like OTMP are very common in the badly lit, improperly maintained wineshops of chennai.

The proper villains of BOYS are the unwanted graphics. Trying his hand on 3D animation Shankar spoils the quality of songs. The BOOM BOOM song is the biggest let down. The 3D animated character of BOYS in-between this song is horrible. It spoiled the feel and the sets of the song. Those unwanted graphic leaves during ALE ALE are also irritating to the core. How can someone like shankar afford to include such cheap animation in the picturesque Tasmania gardens? Also Ravi K Chandran has done an OK job. Not like the powerful shots in Kannathil Muthamitaal.

Shankar’s over-confidence in his art of selling situations to audience has failed this time. Many scenes including the climax look very ordinary without any build-up sequences. Especially that most artificial scene where all the parents meet together just to hear the often-repeated dialogue that television spoils the kids, from vivek. If 22 crores was the original spending for boys, it’s a lavish waste of money.

Coming back to the controversies created by the HYPOCRITIC media and a portion of public who argue that the many scenes in BOYS are obscene and vulgar in nature. Go back a couple of years in the cinema history. The same Chennai had a special screening of Deep Mehta’s Fire exclusively for women in Anand theatre. What a movie to have special screening for women. Surprisingly the show was housefull. A movie that depicts an illegitimate relationship (this type of relationship is still illegitimate in India) between two women, in the same conservative Indian society, is running full houses. But a movie that depicts the lives of five boys as they are is protested to be cut left, right and center to accommodate public interest. Appreciate the height of bias. I’ll have the last laugh. Despite the shortcomings, just for the honesty of filmmaking, I support BOYS. Do you ?

P.S: Read it in Rediff, here

36 thoughts on “Shankar's Boys Movie Review :

  1. Boyz is just another aberration which tries to justify the sexually perverted acts of a bunch of misguided adolescents whose only aim in life seems to chase skirts. Even “Azhiyadha kolangal” was crafted with sensitivity. One doesn’t feel any empathy with even a a single character. Shanker just wanted to cobble up all the urban upmarket “IN” things and miscalculated the youth would savour this mocktail.
    The less said about ARR’s music, the better. BGMs were just fillers.
    Looks like he lost interest halfway thru the film. The climax award winning pop noise was salvaged only due to sane lyrics.
    Even by pop music standards, the climax song “Sa Re Ga Ma “was a big letdown.

  2. Boyz is just another aberration which tries to justify the sexually perverted acts of a bunch of misguided adolescents whose only aim in life seems to chase skirts. Even “Azhiyadha kolangal” was crafted with sensitivity. One doesn’t feel any empathy with even a a single character. Shanker just wanted to cobble up all the urban upmarket “IN” things and miscalculated the youth would savour this mocktail.
    The less said about ARR’s music, the better. BGMs were just fillers.
    Looks like he lost interest halfway thru the film. The climax award winning pop noise was salvaged only due to sane lyrics.
    Even by pop music standards, the climax song “Sa Re Ga Ma “was a big letdown.

  3. This is a response to a post on a different site, but the site was down, so I figured, why not post it here?

    I love Indian movies. I understand how people can see this as a bad movie, but with my experiences in theatre, films, musicals, and culture, this movie tops my all-time favorite, silent film: Across the Sea of Time. Boys shows how great love is, regardless of the modern-day teen. Yes, it shows kids going against their parents and different classes of Indian culture, but people know it’s a movie. I loved it because it also reminded me of Cambodia and our culture. If you don’t like it, you can make your own movie. I liked Boys for its creativity, and it must have cost a lot to make. This movie deserves some sort of Independent Film award, and more should def. see it. I wish I had the soundtrack. I would drive around all day just to listen to it in my car. It’s so romantic, and I wish more people would see how creative and beautiful it is. I like how this movie was created recently, so people like me are able to see that India is a beautiful, modern place. Tell me, how does it show that Indian culture is bad? People are like that in general. Just because it’s based in India doesn’t make it any worse than US culture movies, Asian culture movies, African culture movies, etc. Maybe people are offended because they want everyone to see the good kids and high classes and whatnot, but this really brings all of that together with the characters and international associations. It is an artsy, creative, and wonderfully-directed movie. It does not enrage kids to go “the wrong way.” It shows their mistakes and consequences. It also shows that love, talent, and success are inside of everyone, AND the acting is VERY good. I can’t stand bad acting. All in all, I’m going to buy this movie, the soundtrack, and share it with my friends.

  4. This is a response to a post on a different site, but the site was down, so I figured, why not post it here?

    I love Indian movies. I understand how people can see this as a bad movie, but with my experiences in theatre, films, musicals, and culture, this movie tops my all-time favorite, silent film: Across the Sea of Time. Boys shows how great love is, regardless of the modern-day teen. Yes, it shows kids going against their parents and different classes of Indian culture, but people know it’s a movie. I loved it because it also reminded me of Cambodia and our culture. If you don’t like it, you can make your own movie. I liked Boys for its creativity, and it must have cost a lot to make. This movie deserves some sort of Independent Film award, and more should def. see it. I wish I had the soundtrack. I would drive around all day just to listen to it in my car. It’s so romantic, and I wish more people would see how creative and beautiful it is. I like how this movie was created recently, so people like me are able to see that India is a beautiful, modern place. Tell me, how does it show that Indian culture is bad? People are like that in general. Just because it’s based in India doesn’t make it any worse than US culture movies, Asian culture movies, African culture movies, etc. Maybe people are offended because they want everyone to see the good kids and high classes and whatnot, but this really brings all of that together with the characters and international associations. It is an artsy, creative, and wonderfully-directed movie. It does not enrage kids to go “the wrong way.” It shows their mistakes and consequences. It also shows that love, talent, and success are inside of everyone, AND the acting is VERY good. I can’t stand bad acting. All in all, I’m going to buy this movie, the soundtrack, and share it with my friends.

  5. I love the songs in the movie maybe because im tamil but i havent seen the movie and I think it sounds like a good movie

  6. I love the songs in the movie maybe because im tamil but i havent seen the movie and I think it sounds like a good movie

  7. I’m givin u full support,yaar. Never in my life i’d seen a movie with such perfection, thematically as well as technically. (cut out boom boom)

  8. I’m givin u full support,yaar. Never in my life i’d seen a movie with such perfection, thematically as well as technically. (cut out boom boom)

  9. I loved the movie ! for its honesty ! for sujatha’s dialogues ! shankar’s smart direction !

    you are right ! we have a hypocritic society around us.

  10. I loved the movie ! for its honesty ! for sujatha’s dialogues ! shankar’s smart direction !

    you are right ! we have a hypocritic society around us.

  11. i thot the movie as a whole was very original and shanker has taken a different approach. Even though it may seem that the graphics and screenplay may be silly at times, those are the things that add spice to the movie. As far as iv heard most of the teenagers have enjoyed the movie cuz they can relate to the movie. So all u ppl who r opposin the movie cuz of watever the reason.. just go back a few yrs into ur “pimple ages” and u’ll find the movie to be pretty good. 🙂 plus.. which tamil movie has so many cute boys in a single movie?!;) hhehe

  12. i thot the movie as a whole was very original and shanker has taken a different approach. Even though it may seem that the graphics and screenplay may be silly at times, those are the things that add spice to the movie. As far as iv heard most of the teenagers have enjoyed the movie cuz they can relate to the movie. So all u ppl who r opposin the movie cuz of watever the reason.. just go back a few yrs into ur “pimple ages” and u’ll find the movie to be pretty good. 🙂 plus.. which tamil movie has so many cute boys in a single movie?!;) hhehe

  13. It is only an okay movie. Some songs are good and the dances are really good but the movies is only at an average standard. It’s just a plain movie with nothing that good about it.

  14. new weight loss pill diabetes loss product product weight http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/lipovarin_loss_supplement_weight.html release weight loss product discount weight loss product http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/weight_loss_pill_for_woman.html and …. hottest loss product weight drug loss suv weight http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/discount_loss_supplement_weight.html loss menopause product weight extreme weight loss pill http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/herbal_weight_loss_pill.html _com loss product weight dinitrophenol drug loss weight http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/drug_extreme_loss_weight.html.Thanks.

  15. new weight loss pill diabetes loss product product weight http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/lipovarin_loss_supplement_weight.html release weight loss product discount weight loss product http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/weight_loss_pill_for_woman.html and …. hottest loss product weight drug loss suv weight http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/discount_loss_supplement_weight.html loss menopause product weight extreme weight loss pill http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/herbal_weight_loss_pill.html _com loss product weight dinitrophenol drug loss weight http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/drug_extreme_loss_weight.html.Thanks.

  16. comparison loss supplement weight free weight loss supplement http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/hoodia_loss_pill_weight.html advocare loss product weight dinitrophenol drug loss weight http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/diet_loss_natural_pill_weight.html and …. weight loss product online effective weight loss pill http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/release_weight_loss_supplement.html smoking weight loss drug weight loss product http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/weight_loss_supplement_diet_pill.html drug loss sample weight dr loss phil product weight http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/label_loss_private_product_weight.html.Thanks.

  17. comparison loss supplement weight free weight loss supplement http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/hoodia_loss_pill_weight.html advocare loss product weight dinitrophenol drug loss weight http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/diet_loss_natural_pill_weight.html and …. weight loss product online effective weight loss pill http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/release_weight_loss_supplement.html smoking weight loss drug weight loss product http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/weight_loss_supplement_diet_pill.html drug loss sample weight dr loss phil product weight http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/9/label_loss_private_product_weight.html.Thanks.

  18. love hangover avoiding hangover http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/avoiding_hangover.html bowling for soup a hangover you dont deserve green hangover tea http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/a_hangover_you_don_t_deserve.html and …. hangover remedy a hangover you don t deserve lyric http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_e_card.html worst hangover ever no hangover pill http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/worst_hangover_ever.html no hangover pill curing hangover http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/wine_hangover.html.Thanks.

  19. hangover pill hangover http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_kit.html hangover vitamin the offspring the worst hangover ever lyric http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/how_to_get_over_a_hangover.html and …. hangover msn hangover cure home remedy http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_defense.html drug hangover hangover helper http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_recipe.html honky tonk hangover hangover tip http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_cure_home_remedy.html.Thanks.

  20. hangover pill hangover http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_kit.html hangover vitamin the offspring the worst hangover ever lyric http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/how_to_get_over_a_hangover.html and …. hangover msn hangover cure home remedy http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_defense.html drug hangover hangover helper http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_recipe.html honky tonk hangover hangover tip http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_cure_home_remedy.html.Thanks.

  21. b12 vitamin hangover hangover http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/how_to_avoid_a_hangover.html hangover joke hangover cafe http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/wine_hangover.html and …. mexican hangover treating a hangover http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/neverending_hangover.html hangover prevention formula hangover home remedy http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/no_hangover.html hangover treatment a hangover you don t deserve lyric http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_cure.html.Thanks.

  22. alcohol hangover hangover smoothies http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_dont.html bowling soup hangover you bowling soup hangover you http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/map.html and …. the offspring the worst hangover ever lyric chaser hangover pill http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/worst_hangover.html no hangover how to get rid of a hangover http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/anti_hangover_pill.html hangover relief hangover fountain http://yasamohuel.myhome.cx/8/hangover_joke.html.Thanks.

  23. Thillana’s Mann Vaasam

    Guest Blog 7 – Anand Chandrasekharan Oorai Vittu Veruooru Vandhaalum, unakku ullirukkum Mann Vasam Naarai Vittu Poo Uthirndhaalum, Nalla Manama Veesum Mann Vasam Yaarai Marandhaalum, Yenna Muyandralum, Marakka Mudiyadhu Mann Vasam Paaraikku Naduvula Pa…

  24. Thillana’s Mann Vaasam

    Guest Blog 7 – Anand Chandrasekharan Oorai Vittu Veruooru Vandhaalum, unakku ullirukkum Mann Vasam Naarai Vittu Poo Uthirndhaalum, Nalla Manama Veesum Mann Vasam Yaarai Marandhaalum, Yenna Muyandralum, Marakka Mudiyadhu Mann Vasam Paaraikku Naduvula Pa…

  25. WASHINGTON – The White House said Thursday it was investigating whether Iran’s new president played a role in seizing the American Embassy and holding 52 U.S. captives a quarter century ago. President Bush said the allegation by former hostages “raises many questions.”
    Cheap Software – download microsoft software

  26. WASHINGTON – The White House said Thursday it was investigating whether Iran’s new president played a role in seizing the American Embassy and holding 52 U.S. captives a quarter century ago. President Bush said the allegation by former hostages “raises many questions.”
    Cheap Software – download microsoft software

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: